SPOILERS GALORE.
I have been actively forgiving of
How I Met Your Mother. Any show that banks on a single grand arc runs the risk of landing exactly where HIMYM is now, and that risk is entirely out of the creators' and writers' hands. Shows get cancelled and extended all the time. They introduced Victoria in season 1 thinking they'd get cancelled and at least their story would have worked as a backup. I'm guessing here, but I'd say around mid-season 5, they had a seven-year plan. Now, their unbridled success has painted them in a corner, and they've had to spin their wheels out to a ninth season. The premise has long since run its course, but the show must go on.
I have trudged through every awful episode because once upon a time, series creator Carter Bays promised he had an ending in mind the whole time that would make it all worth it. He was supposedly overseeing every episode, so no matter what happened, it would align with this grand ending. When filming the
Harry Potter movies, J.K. Rowling told only Alan Rickman the truth behind Snape. That way, every scene he played, especially with Harry, would ring true with the final reveal. Bays made a promise to us all. Even though the show isn't exactly how they want it anymore, the big ending will make it all worth it.
Last night's episode, "Vesuvius," seems to point to one conclusion: the Mother is dying, and they know it six years before 2030, the year Ted is telling this epic story. In my humble opinion, this would ruin the entire series. Even if the ending itself is sweet and heartfelt in ways only HIMYM can nail, it would destroy everything that came before it.
Keep Reading >>Labels: essay, TV